GreedFall 2 will probably run into Red Dead Redemption 2’s problems

Highlights

• GreedFall 2, like Red Dead Redemption 2, faces the challenge of introducing new characters and events without contradicting established canon.
• A prequel can enrich a game’s story, but care must be taken not to confuse or contradict anything that has already happened.
• GreedFall 2 can take players to a different section of the world, allowing for more world-building and possible connections to the first game through companions.

Greed is a historical fantasy action RPG set in an 18th century style world of exploration and colonization with elements of mysticism and the supernatural. The 2019 title feels in many ways like a lost BioWare game, serving to fill a void left in the genre at a time when it and other similar AAA studios seemed to be chasing the live-service trend rather than creating a single-player focus. . On the heels of the games Greed‘s success, developer Spiders announced GreedFall 2: The Dying WorldIt’s set for release sometime later this year, and there will be a prequel that takes place about three years earlier GF1

.

Meanwhile, Rockstar’s Red Dead Redemption 2 Almost no introduction is needed. A sprawling open-world western with an epic and emotionally gripping yarn that explores themes of honor, sacrifice and self-reflection, in a world full of incredible detail. RDR2 Considered a masterpiece in the medium. Even as a prequel, it fleshed out many familiar characters and introduced new ones. However, prequels of this nature come with their own narrative risks. As a case in point, RDR2Although a heavy influence on the main character, Arthur Morgan, was never referenced in the original entry. RDR1 The past and present situation of the protagonist John Marston. While the reason is obvious, just that the character didn’t exist before, this can sometimes create dissonance for the audience, and GF2 This may also have to be grappled with.

GreedFall 2 may face a similar Red Dead Redemption 2 story issue

The dilemma of prequels as sequels

While there’s nothing inherently wrong with prequels, they can create a few hurdles that a direct sequel or setting a story much further back than the previous one can’t. It’s often at least a little unsettling when IP retroactively changes something significantly or introduces a major aspect that doesn’t seem to have been previously set up or hinted at. When what is believed to be a personally important character or series of events in Leeds’s life is inserted into the story after not being present previously, fans accept it and expect the characters to behave as naturally as they often feel. That, it has the possibility of misfiring.

Even if it’s in the service of expanding and improving the story, it can stretch believability and erode some of the groundwork already laid. For example, in retrospect it is strange that Arthur Morgan is not mentioned RDR Despite being so important in its prequel. When handled well, however, a prequel can enrich a story and add interesting dynamics and layers to it.

How GreedFall 2 Can Avoid Red Dead Redemption 2’s Conundrum

like Red Dead Redemption 2, Greed 2 will feature a new main character, and possibly the events of Greed 2No plot will have at least some consistency and bearing with the first. But again, since that story is apparently complete, it would require any revelations or crossovers so that it doesn’t resolve or contradict anything that’s already happened. Given the nature of Greed’s setting and the time frame of the prequel, it would be strange for the previous protagonist de Surdet to be unaware of any important discoveries or major events that occurred during that time. GF2campaign of

It may be the case that Greed 2 Players will be transported to an entirely different section of Gakken’s sprawling continent, allowing for more world-building to be shown without having to contain it. GF1The story is straightforward. maybe GF2 De Sardet or any of the first would not mention the other main characters, or if so, only in passing, in order to maintain overall coherence without distorting the established theory. Greed 2‘s colleagues can provide a mechanism for resolving any conflicts that arise, as they can fill in gaps and connect tangentially. GF1. Exactly how remains to be seen GF2 will fit into and interact with the existing plot, but will likely require Spiders to carefully balance elements and viewpoints for a seamless experience.